Ask Bob
Q: What does 'The Lord of the Rings' say to us about God?

The book ‘The Lord of the Rings’ was ”a fundamentally religious and Christian work” according to its author Tolkien. Does it express Christian truths in a way we can pass on to our friends or colleagues – to those who may love Tolkien’s work but wouldn’t go to church if you paid them?

The book’s (and the film’s) attitude toward heroism is deeply Christian. The true hero of the story is not the cleverest, or strongest, or wisest or most powerful - in fact, he’s quite the opposite. Small, helpless, almost insignificant, Frodo Baggins has all the heroic qualities of Ronnie Corbett; yet his willingness to go to his almost certain death so that the Ring may be destroyed, and the earth saved, makes him the most important member of the team. ‘God chose the foolish things of the world to shame the wise; [He] chose the weak things of the world to shame the strong’ (1 Corinthians 1.27).

Let’s look at the Ring itself. The power available to anyone who uses the Ring is portrayed – in the book and the film - as seductive and addictive. Previous owners of the Ring, even good-hearted ones like Bilbo Baggins, are shown to be almost enslaved by it, while its promise of power tempts even the most high-minded members of the fellowship.

The corrupting power of the Ring clearly represents evil and sin – it’s an image of what happens when a human being gives in to desires that seem harmless at first and end up consuming him. Moreover, Tolkien’s Ring is not neutral; a good-hearted person cannot use it in order to achieve good. It ultimately corrupts anyone who seeks to control it.

This is an important point, and opposes the viewpoint expressed in most other works of fantasy. In these, the Ring (or Sword, or Cloak) of power is neutral; an evil person can use it for evil, but a good person can also use it for good if their ‘heart is strong enough’. Tolkien says ‘No’ – such a source of earthly power will always ultimately take control of the person using it, no matter how strong their heart is. This reflects Christian theology, which states that we cannot overcome our own tendency to sin by our own efforts. Our only hope is to be rescued from it.

And it’s this perspective that most clearly highlights Tolkien’s Christian viewpoint. All the other characters are involved in great sweeping battles against the enemy - yet all their efforts will come to nothing if Frodo fails in his quest. The Fellowship of the Ring can fight evil all it wants, but ultimately its - and the earth’s - only hope lies in being delivered from evil by the successful fulfillment of one person’s task. It’s a definition of heroism that Tolkien took straight from the Bible.

Two thousand years ago, a carpenter’s son - conceived out of wedlock in a tiny country under the occupation of one of the most powerful empires the world had then seen - was born in a cave used to keep animals. He grew up to become a charismatic speaker who drew huge crowds of people to hear what he had to say. He had the chance to use his popularity to lead an uprising against the occupying forces and cast off the yoke of oppression beneath which his fellow countrymen suffered. Instead, he allowed himself to be arrested, unfairly tried, tortured and then to suffer perhaps the most horrific form of execution ever practiced. Why?

To give us the only possible escape route from the forces of evil that seek to over-run and enslave this world. The evil that continually tells us that our highest priority is to look after our own concerns and comforts before anyone else’s. The evil that has blinded us into believing that if we ’do our best’, then we can earn God’s favour. Like the Ring of Power, it tempts us with promises of power (or freedom, or sex, or happiness), but ends up ruling us. Moreover, our bravest, most noble and selfless actions can’t buy us the mercy and forgiveness we all desperately need. God has every right to abandon us as punishment for rebelling against His rule over us.

Yet in His love for us, God’s son came to earth and poured His life out for us. When Jesus died on the cross, he took the punishment we deserve for rejecting God. When he rose from the dead, he destroyed the power that sin has over us. The way back to the loving Father is now open by Jesus’ sacrifice. God’s grace, peace and forgiveness is there for the asking. Will you ask Him for it?

Agree? Disagree? Want to ask another question? Contact me at askbob@kingsnews.org.uk

 

KN Magazines on-line:
 
     
Top of page

This site and all pages copyright 2009
Tavistock Community Church - registered charity no. 801576